A recent U.S. study challenges assumptions about the link between prescription stimulant use for ADHD and later substance abuse. Adolescents who used prescription stimulants under a physician’s supervision did not exhibit increased rates of non-medical stimulant use or cocaine use as they transitioned into young adulthood. However, other factors, like binge drinking and cannabis use, showed significant associations with later substance misuse, suggesting that the landscape of risk is more complex than previously understood.
Stimulants and ADHD: Understanding the Risks
Prescription stimulants are considered one of the most effective treatments for ADHD. While these medications can significantly improve focus and behavior, concerns have persisted that using stimulants during adolescence might predispose individuals to substance use disorder (SUD). Some theories suggest that early exposure to stimulants could increase the likelihood of cocaine use, as both substances affect the brain's dopamine pathways similarly.
Yet, previous research often lacked large, longitudinal studies focusing on adolescents with ADHD who had never been treated with stimulants. To fill this gap, a research team followed a nationally representative cohort of 11,905 high school seniors (12th graders, mostly aged 18) for six years, tracking their substance use behaviors.
Study Design: Following the Participants
At the start of the study, participants completed surveys regarding their ADHD treatment history—whether they had used stimulant therapy, non-stimulant therapy, or no medication at all. This formed three groups:
- Adolescents treated with stimulant therapy for ADHD
- Adolescents treated with non-stimulant therapy for ADHD (ADHD controls)
- Adolescents with no history of ADHD treatment (non-ADHD controls)
Participants then completed follow-up surveys every two years, reporting on their use of substances like prescription stimulants and cocaine, as well as their engagement in behaviors like binge drinking and cannabis use.
Key Findings: No Direct Link to Non-medical Stimulant or Cocaine Use
The study found no significant differences in the rates of non-medical stimulant use or cocaine use among the three groups. Adolescents who had been prescribed stimulant medications were not more likely to misuse prescription stimulants or cocaine as young adults than those who had not received such medications.
However, other behaviors at age 18 showed strong associations with later substance use:
- Binge drinking during late adolescence was linked to an 80% increase in the likelihood of subsequent nonmedical prescription stimulant use and cocaine use.
- Nonmedical use of prescription opioids at age 18 increased the odds of later nonmedical stimulant use by 50% and of cocaine use by two-thirds.
- Cannabis use by age 18 more than tripled the likelihood of later non-medical stimulant use and increased the odds of subsequent cocaine use sixfold.
Clinical Implications
The study’s findings have important implications for both clinicians and families managing ADHD. Although ADHD is associated with an increased risk of SUD, the researchers observed no higher risk of nonmedical stimulant use among adolescents who had taken stimulant therapy compared to those who hadn’t. Additionally, there was no evidence that stimulant medications posed a greater risk than non-stimulant medications for subsequent misuse.
The findings also highlight the need for more robust screening for alcohol and other drug use among adolescents. As the study notes, current guidelines do not recommend routine screening for substance misuse in adolescents due to limited evidence. However, given the associations found between binge drinking, cannabis use, and later substance misuse, such preventive measures could play a key role in reducing risks during this vulnerable period of development.
Ultimately, the study sheds light on the multifaceted nature of substance use risks in adolescents and young adults, suggesting that while prescription stimulant use for ADHD under medical supervision may not directly contribute to substance abuse, the broader context of an adolescent’s behaviors and environment is crucial in shaping future outcomes.
Vita V. McCabe, Philip T. Veliz, Timothy E. Wilens, Ty S. Schepis, Emily Pasman, Rebecca J. Evans-Polce, and Sean Esteban McCabe, “Adolescents’ Use of Medications for Attention-Deficit/ Hyperactivity Disorder and Subsequent Risk of Nonmedical Stimulant Use,” Journal of Adolescent Health (2024), https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jadohealth.2024.01.024.
_logo%201.svg)
